Following a successful 26-game loan spell at Port Vale during the first part of the 2023/24 campaign, Arblaster returned to S2 and impressed in 12 top-flight appearances, making his debut against Arsenal at Bramall Lane.

The boyhood Blade who has been associated with the club since his junior years and has progressed through the ranks, then captained United for the first time at Old Trafford in April 2024 and is contracted at Bramall Lane until the summer of 2028.